Wednesday, November 4

Despite a Major outranking a Captain...


...doesn't Captain Rhodes beat the piss outta Major West in the asshole-military-commandeer-in-an-undead-apocalypse sweepstakes?

Ran into the old pain last night while watching 28 Days Later.... Danny Boyle's film has some of the most affecting imagery in a British post-apocalyptic funeral dirge since Mick Jackson's Threads. The immensity of waking up to completely desolate, human-refuse littered streets in the shadow of Big Ben and the London Eye. The missing persons-plastered billboard around the memorial foundation in Piccadilly Circus. When Jim reads the "don't wake up..." note left by his deceased parents. Mark's recollection of losing his family in a crowd and having no recourse but to climb over the dead to escape the infected. The reflections in the taxi's window of piles of ashen bodies accompanied by an abandoned bulldozer. The simple joy of seeing a family of horses running free amidst mankind's darkest hour. Irradiated apples. Just amazing stuff. The kind of incidental stuff long imagined being great if ever filmed in the heads of I Am Legend fans.

Then they reach the blockade, eventually the mansion compound, and the story dissolves into a forced clusterfuck of "military = bad" scenarios. This is also where comparisons can be made (and have definitely been made) with the pigheaded military men of Romero's Day of the Dead. Both films tackle many of the same questions concerning armed forces in globally dire circumstances. What's the worth of having a command hierarchy when there's nothing to left to defend? Wouldn't the remaining military essentially become people that know how to fire a weapon with an all-encompassing enemy in the billions? How much or little logic could piss the wrong person off? How real are the allusions to rape from fighting men who still believe their macho bullshit impresses? All questions ripe for interpretation and Romero scribbles in the essay with better answers.

Christopher Eccleston's performance as Major West in 28 Days Later is as stale as the rotting bread in the supermarket stop on the way to the Manchester blockade. The sell is on his shoulders and Eccleston fumbles the keys with no sense of leadership and not even a hint of messianic Charlie Manson flare with his vaguely God-like position over the armed frat boys in camo. West promises his men women to end their "no future" woes. So why does the arrival of Selena and Hanna herald the coming of these "women"? Are the soldiers that easily swayed and devoid of common human decency? Of course, the Sergeant that protests West's command is walked out along with Jim for a woodland execution.

I personally find this portrayal of extreme loss of professional tact and basic morality within the unit insulting. Boyle and Garland paint with too broad of a stroke in casting nearly every solider some loathsome ogre in a pact driven by bloodlust and self-gratifying degradation from a mere "promise." Seriously? Doesn't it seem odd West's men don't just off Jim on sight along with Hannah's infected father if all they were interested in were Selena and Hannah's naughty bits? It also spits in the face of womanhood as we see the once fiercely independent and resourceful Selena almost willingly become a pawn to the whims of West's boys before her timely rescue by a man. This exercise in the last half of the film reeks of a trite knee-jerk political shot from-the-hip and sours the entire body of work.

Romero's Day of the Dead isn't fixated on the rape question besides several one-off remarks, but Joe Pilato's turn as Captain Rhodes makes Eccleston's West look like a little boy playing army. The actor plays Rhodes incredibly over-the-top and gloriously sells the domineering military leader role out of sheer bullish fortitude. Rhodes is a screaming hardline thug with a six-shooter that still believes in his own shit despite the six billion strong walking dead population above his head. Rhodes' men follow him out of a mix of fear and the sense of empowerment his overwhelming never say die personality exudes over the pissant scientists. The men also exhibit an awareness of right and wrong regardless of command when Rhodes demands Private Steel at gunpoint to execute Sarah for not sitting down unlike the faceless soldiers of the other film this entry concerns. In the end, Rhodes and crew get their proper comeupins for their ignorance and abhorrence toward their fellow man. The same fate befalls West and men in 28 Days Later, but did you really give a damn at that point?

Ultimately, Eccleston's West and his men possess none of these traits making 28 Day Later's point of conflict seem meaningless and everything the film tries to say collapses to its half baked conclusion. Except for environmentalists being the cause of the near downfall of the human race. That was heard loud and clear. At least Boyle's misfired effort makes my appreciation for Romero's once maligned third Dead entry only deepen. This is how it's done no matter how many artsy shots a director crams in.

HorrorBlips: vote it up!

6 comments:

Drunketh said...

Seriously, I think all of Rhode's scenes are the best! He's probably the main reason I fell in love with Day... when that soundtrack hits and he gets all serious eyed and shit... ahhh yeahzz..

Anthony1138 said...

The degree of crazy that West & co. succumbed to in such a short period of time always bothered me. I get what Boyle was doing there, but it just doesn't jive with the rest of the film. It feels forced and almost a little silly at times.

Given the longer exposure to the "apocalypse" in Day, Rhodes' military outfit (or whatever was left of it) is much more believable. His men are loyal to him and the military hierarchy they are so desperately trying to hold on to, but by no means are they brainwashed like the troops in 28 Days.

And let's not forget that in Day, they were living in a fucking underground cave with millions of zombies creeping around overhead. Of course you're gonna go a little crazy. At least the schmucks in 28 Days had a some nice comfy digs to knock around in with a scenic view and a secure perimeter setup to keep them safe. What was their excuse for drinking the Kool-Aid so easily?

Knarf Black XIV said...

"I'm running this monkey farm now, Frankenstein!"

Pretty much every line he spews forth is gold.

Drunketh said...

Well Tony138, it's like that old saying: Taste of power, taste a flower. ;) Know what I'm sayin'?

Jayson said...

Also Anthony, remember West's "answer" to infection was seeing how long it takes for an infected to starve to death. That only makes the quickness of the soldier's fall in depravity odder. I mean any rational person would say that wouldn't take that long...in the film it only took a month longer.

Anthony1138 said...

So Drunketh, are you saying that the soldiers in 28 Days turned gay with power? Because I never bought for a second that any of them were gonna rape anyone, except maybe Jim. ;)

Yeah, that's another good point Jay. I think I need to revisit both of these films one day as a double feature...

...do you dare tread upon the staircase?
Basement of Ghoulish Decadence, Basement of Ghoulish Archive, and all original material Copyright © 2009-present by Jayson Kennedy. All rights reserved.